By Paul NewberryASSOCIATED PRESS
CONYERS,
Ga. – Chad Frazier has seen it hundreds of times: Two guys run
into each other at full speed, and one of them doesn't get up right
away.
The crowd falls silent. The other players drop to a knee,
whispering a prayer and trying to shake the very sobering reality that
it could be any of them stretched out on the ground. Everyone strains
their eyes, hoping to glimpse even the tiniest sign of movement.
As
the head football coach at Heritage High School in suburban Atlanta,
Frazier knows most players eventually get up. Still, he always frets
that one won't.
“Every time there's a collision and one of
my kids falls to the ground, the worst goes through my mind,”
Frazier said. “It may only be his pride is hurt because he just
got whipped. But if they don't move right away, the worst goes through
my mind.”
That worst-case scenario played out in Buffalo
last weekend. Kevin Everett charged in to make a tackle on a kickoff
return, but he appeared to duck his head a split-second before making
contact, leaving himself with a catastrophic spinal-cord injury.
At
first, doctors feared the Bills tight end would never walk again. In
fact, his very life was in danger. In the following days, Everett
showed encouraging signs of movement, improving the odds that he'll
live something of a normal life, even though his football career is
surely over.
Whatever the outcome, Everett's case demonstrates
the enormous risks that all football players face, especially when they
give in to the natural tendency to look down just before a collision.
Think
of it this way: What would a motorist instinctively do when his car is
about to run into something? Duck, of course. But that's the worst
mistake a football player can make.
“It's a technique that
is not easily mastered, and it's very easily done wrong,” said
Pierson Prioleau, a ninth-year safety with the Washington Redskins.
“And, trust me, when you turn the game film on, 90 percent of the
time you're going to see it done wrong. But 99.9 percent of the time,
nobody has to pay for it injury wise.”
When someone does, the price can be enormously high.
Last
year alone, the National Center for Catastrophic Sport Injury Research
logged 10 spinal-cord cases on the gridiron. Since 1977, at least 269
sandlot, high school, college and pro players have gone down with that
most feared of injuries, the group reports.
Marc Buoniconti, son
of NFL Hall of Famer Nick Buoniconti, has been paralyzed from the neck
down since making a tackle for The Citadel in 1985. He and his father
now work closely with the Miami Project to Cure Paralysis, one of the
world's top neurological research centers.
“It was ironic
in a way,” the younger Buoniconti said. “Football gave us
our greatest joy and our worst sorrow.”
Although no one can
eliminate the risk of life-changing injuries in such a violent sport,
football has taken steps to reduce the chances. There are now strict
rules against “spearing” – diving into another player
with the top of the helmet. A couple of years ago, the NCAA outlawed
all helmet-to-helmet contact, intentional or not.
Ron Courson, the head athletic trainer at the University of Georgia, led the effort.
“Heads
up – that's the key,” said Courson, who helped develop a
14-minute video with that title, “Heads Up,” to spread the
message through all levels of football. “If you can see what you
hit, you're not going to rule out every injury, but you're going to be
significantly safer.”
Research started in the early 1970s,
when it wasn't uncommon for more than 30 players a year to sustain
paralyzing injuries. Dr. Joseph Torg of Temple University led a
groundbreaking study that found most of the devastating injuries
occurred when a tackler made initial contact with the top of his helmet.
“The
neck has a normal curvature in it. That's important, because it allows
some shock absorbency in the neck,” Courson explained. “But
when you initiate contact with the top of your head, you have to bend
your neck down. The spine becomes straight and doesn't have the ability
to absorb the shock as well.”
Those risks are even greater in today's game, with bigger, faster, stronger players creating ever more violent collisions.
“When
you have a 200-pound defensive player running into a 200-pound
offensive player at a high rate of speed, that's a significant
collision,” Courson said. “When you stop very suddenly, the
deceleration force goes through the spine. Something has to give.”
The
most serious cases result in a “burst fracture” of the
Vertebrae, which sends small fragments of bone flying into the spinal
column. Paralysis is often the result, though it varies from case to
case how much of the body is affected and whether the victim is left
permanently disabled.
Everett might be one of the lucky ones,
though Buoniconti disputed those who call it a miracle. He pointed to
the quick care Everett received from medical personnel at the stadium,
along with advances such as “Hypothermia therapy” that were
developed by the Miami Project and other programs.
The Bills
player's body was flushed with cold fluids to lower his temperature, a
process that reduces the inflammation around the spinal column.
Basically, it's a much more advanced version of a player putting ice on
a sore knee.
“That has been a real shot in the arm for our
research,” Buoniconti said. “Now we have to continue to
work to allow people all over this country, all over the world, to
utilize it like Kevin did. It should be protocol for anyone who has a
spinal-cord injury.”
The NFL's charitable wing donates $1.5
million a year for medical research but has gradually shifted away from
spinal-cord projects. “We've been focusing most of that in recent
years on concussion-related research,” league spokesman Greg
Aiello said.
Others are trying to prevent this sort of injury from happening in the first place.
USA
Football, charged with growing the sport at the grass-roots level,
holds coaching clinics around the country and provides online teaching
tools that show the benefits of proper technique, especially when it
comes to the two most basic fundaments: blocking and tackling.
Of
course, most youth coaches are volunteers, usually adults who have kids
on the team or love to watch football on the weekends. Many times, they
don't know the best and latest drills. They might figure the best way
to teach a youngster to tackle (and rid him of his natural fear and
hesitancy) is to send him charging at another player from several feet
away.
Not so, said Scott Hallenbeck, the executive director of USA Football.
“You
should start with the kids inches apart. They should be banging
facemasks,” he said. “Then they should go shoulder pads to
shoulder pads. You slowly move them back, just inches at first, then a
few feet. But they should never be more than a few feet apart.”
Some leagues do it right. Some don't.
Frazier, who's been coaching at the high school level for 10 years, sees a huge disparity by the time those players get to him.
“You
can tell the ones who have played and been taught to do it the right
way. They do a good job of keeping their hips low, their knees bent and
their heads up,” he said. “The ones who haven't played or
haven't been taught, they have a tendency to duck their head.”
Even
the NFL's best players struggle to maintain the form that is drilled
into their heads every day by the coaches, but just doesn't feel right
once they get on the field.
“That's the hard part about
tackling, man,” Washington Redskins linebacker Randall Godfrey
said. “You try to use perfect form. We teach it every day. We go
through it. But when you're on special teams, you're running down there
on kickoffs and things are going wide open, it's hard to control how
you place your head and make a tackle.”
Everett was hurt on
a kickoff return, when the risks are amplified by the fact that both
teams have more room to run at each other.
Georgia coach Mark
Richt was troubled by the NCAA's decision to move back kickoffs this
year to the 30-yard line – which the NFL already used – in
hopes of creating more returns than touchbacks.
“I don't
necessarily dislike the kickoff. I just know it's a dangerous
play,” Richt said. “It's exciting. If I was a fan, I would
love it. But as a coach, I see how hard these guys run into each other.
I just worry about those guys.”
Even with the increased
emphasis on safety and improved equipment, there hasn't been the sort
of decline in catastrophic injuries that one might expect, according to
the national research center.
In fact, after reporting
single-digit case numbers for all but one year from 1991-2002, there
have been at least 10 spinal cord injuries in three of the last four
years (the exception was 2005, with only three cases).
Cincinnati Bengals coach Marvin Lewis blames a breakdown in teaching methods all along the football pipeline.
“Young
kids don't go out and play football in the street anymore,” he
said. “Colleges can't spend as much time with their guys on the
field. Their spring football is limited, how much contact and so forth.
So it becomes a game of non-contact until you have contact. With that,
we're going to continually see more instances of guys injured like
(Everett).”
Prioleau, the Redskins safety, said at least
two times every game he gets up from a tackle with his neck stinging
– and has to remind himself to use proper technique the next time.
“You're
like 'whew,' but it happens all the time and you never really think
about it,” he said. “You know it's part of the game. It's
why you say your prayers before the game, you say them after the game,
and you continue to play.”
AP Sports Writers Joseph White in Washington and Joe Kay in Cincinnati contributed to this report.